Skip to main content

Analysis of Market Breadth

 The SPY is essentially at all time highs, but it is important to have some sort of skepticism here. It should be known that there are only a select few of stocks in the SPX index that are driving the majority of performance. For example, the SPX is at a YTD return of +6.07%, while the S&P 500 equal-weighting index (EWI) (each company in the SPX get equal weighting, instead of the index being weighted on market capitalization) has a YTD return of -13.42%. 

This goes to show the complacency in identifying the negative aspects in relation to the SPX's return. There is a clear discrepancy within the individual market breadth, one that has rarely been seen before. There is also a growing complacency by investors who are clearly unaware of the underlying systematic risks at play below the casual surface area of price. For instance, we will examine Apple. Apple is about 7% of all holdings in the SPX tracking ETF, SPY. Also, the top 5 holdings for the SPY ETF (AAPL, MSFT, AMZN, FB, GOOGL) have 21.58% of the proportional weighting of the index, who just happen to be up incredible amounts YTD. 
Apple's underlying volatility complex (VXAPL) has risen 116.45% YTD, with the underlying rising an incredible 64.77% YTD. Furthermore, Apple's volatility when it peaked versus the prior 15 day, and approximate 1 month average were both up +25.11% and +30.74% respectively. This means one of two things. First off, with this great bull run, the standard deviation of outcomes has subsequently widened at an incredible rate. Also, when Apple made all-time highs of $134.18 on September 1st, its volume on that trading day was down -32.45% versus the prior day, and -21.08% versus the prior 15 days. This is possibly the worst combination to have when analyzing any given security using a multi-factor model like I just employed (price, volume, and volatility).  Normally, when you are long a given security, you want price to rise, volume to rise, and volatility to fall. This was clearly not the case. A significant pullback to the down side was clearly imminent (from peak, Apple fell approximately -10% to the most recent close). 

I hope this quick analysis helps some readers to consider that there is more to consider than simply the price of a given security. 







Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

One Last Ride

Since my previous post, the S&P 500 has appreciated +3.19% to $4,535.43, with the VIX and VVIX depreciating by -10.03% and -9.21% to 16.41 and 105.48, respectively. My last callout only truly referenced how participants were pricing butterfly securities, implied correlation, and general futures and options positioning in terms of notional contracts. Even then, it was apparent a decent portion of the market (particularly on the ES side) was extremely bearish, with the vast majority being bullish (as evidenced by a lower VIX/VVIX/vol contract positing, etc.). From peak to trough of the S&P500's worst week in several months, on 8/13/2021 to 8/19/2021, the VIX appreciated by over 40% from 15.45 to 21.67, the SPX falling -1.39% from 4468 to 4405.80, and the VVIX appreciating by over 10% from 117.81 to 130.41. As was stated in the previous post, the primary risk factor to be considered was an overreaction in implied volatility, which was clearly seen in this time frame.  One more...
Post a Comment
Read more

A Potential Short-Sell Opportunity

In my previous post, the S&P 500 was at all-time-highs before dropping to almost -1.5% intraday as of this post. I highlighted how market participants, particularly those with superior information, were positioning for a moderate pullback in the short term. This post will explain the potential opportunity resulting from this pullback.  Market Breadth I would first like to mention a simple, yet power multi-factor model that incorporates price, volume, and volatility. As of today's close, the SPY's (an ETF that tracks the S&P 500 index) volume on today's poor performance (SPY rebounded from nearly -1.4% to -0.62%) accelerated against its previous trading day, 5 day volume average, 15 day volume average, 30 day volume average, as well as the 90 day volume average by +47.72%, +50.32%, +44.40%, +30.14%, and +29.69%, respectively, with the VIX index climbing by +6.39% to 19.48. This is what you do not want to see as a bullish investor with respect to volume by market part...
Post a Comment
Read more

What the heck is a skew?

 As a firm believer in the advantages in volatility timing for one's market timing strategies rather than simply traditional surface area of price market timing, I analyze a decent amount of data in the derivatives space. More specifically, the futures and options markets. I focus on ES contracts, which are essentially futures contracts that track the S&P 500 index, but are quoted in smaller notional values than traditional futures contracts on the S&P 500 index, which allows for more liquidity (more people are able to play with more contracts since it is more affordable) and better price discovery (with more market participants on this product, there is inherently more information conveyed, so the chances of arbitrage strategies as a result of an inefficient pricing of the given product is much less likely than the traditional futures contracts). In order to get a sense of what volatility might look like in the future (implied volatility), I analyze options on those ES con...
Post a Comment
Read more